Evaluation Grid - Final Project

Technical Evaluation (60 points)

Architecture and Structure (15 points)

Criteria	Points	0	1-2	3-4	5
MVC Structure	5	Absent	Partial	Good	Excellent
Layer Separation	5	Mixed	Partial	Clear	Perfect
DTOs	5	Absent	Some	Complete	With mapping

REST API (15 points)

Criteria	Points	0	1-2	3-4	5
CRUD Endpoints	5	Incomplete	Basic	Complete	With pagination
HTTP Codes	3	Incorrect	Partial	Correct	-
Validation	5	Absent	Basic	Complete	With messages
Error Handling	2	Absent	Basic	-	-

Persistence (15 points)

Criteria	Points	0	1-2	3-4	5
Spring Data JPA	5	Absent	Basic	Complete	Optimized
Relations	5	Absent	Simple	Complex	With cascade
Custom Queries	3	Absent	Query methods	@Query	-
Transactions	2	Absent	Basic	-	-

Security (15 points)

Criteria	Points	0	1-2	3-4	5
Spring Security	5	Absent	Basic	Configured	Complete
JWT	5	Absent	Basic	Complete	With refresh
Roles/Permissions	4	Absent	Basic	Complete	With @PreAuthorize
Password encoding	1	Absent	Present	-	-

---

Test Evaluation (15 points)

Criteria	Points	0	1-3	4-6	7+
Unit Tests	5	0 tests	1-4	5-9	10+
Integration Tests	5	0 tests	1-2	3-4	5+
Coverage	5	Less than 30%	30-50%	50-70%	More than 70%

---

Code Quality Evaluation (15 points)

Criteria	Points	Description
Readability	5	Clear code, well indented, consistent naming
Comments	3	Javadoc on public methods, relevant comments
Best Practices	4	No duplicated code, SOLID, DRY
Configuration	3	Profiles, externalized properties

---

Documentation Evaluation (10 points)

Criteria	Points	Description
README	4	Description, installation, execution
API Documentation	3	Documented endpoints
Instructions	3	Clear user guide

---

Bonus (30 points maximum)

Feature	Points	Criteria
Redis Cache	5	Configuration + functional annotations
RabbitMQ Messaging	5	Functional Producer + Consumer
WebSocket	5	Functional real-time
Docker	5	Functional Dockerfile + docker-compose
CI/CD	5	GitHub Actions with build + tests
Swagger/OpenAPI	5	Complete API documentation
Monitoring	5	Actuator + custom metrics
Microservices	10	2+ services + communication

---

Final Grading Scale

Grade	Points	Description
A+	95-100	Exceptional
A	90-94	Excellent
A-	85-89	Very good
B+	80-84	Good
B	75-79	Satisfactory
B-	70-74	Acceptable
C+	65-69	Passable
C	60-64	Minimum
D	50-59	Insufficient
F	Less than 50	Fail

---

Penalties

Infraction	Penalty
Late	-5% per day
Plagiarism	0 + disciplinary measures
Non-compilable code	-20%
Non-executable application	-30%
Missing README	-10%

---

Evaluation Sheet

Student: _______________________
Project: _________________________
Date: ___________________________

TECHNICAL EVALUATION (60 pts)
[ ] Architecture and Structure    ___/15
[ ] REST API                     ___/15
[ ] Persistence                  ___/15
[ ] Security                     ___/15

TESTS (15 pts)
[ ] Unit Tests                   ___/5
[ ] Integration Tests            ___/5
[ ] Coverage                     ___/5

CODE QUALITY (15 pts)
[ ] Readability                  ___/5
[ ] Comments                     ___/3
[ ] Best Practices               ___/4
[ ] Configuration                ___/3

DOCUMENTATION (10 pts)
[ ] README                       ___/4
[ ] API Documentation            ___/3
[ ] Instructions                 ___/3

SUBTOTAL: ___/100

BONUS
[ ] Redis Cache                  ___/5
[ ] RabbitMQ Messaging           ___/5
[ ] WebSocket                    ___/5
[ ] Docker                       ___/5
[ ] CI/CD                        ___/5
[ ] Swagger/OpenAPI              ___/5
[ ] Monitoring                   ___/5
[ ] Microservices                ___/10

TOTAL BONUS: ___/30

PENALTIES: ___

FINAL TOTAL: ___

Comments:
_________________________________
_________________________________
_________________________________

Evaluator: _____________________
Signature: ______________________

---

Back to Final Project